Zero-depreciation (nil-dep): how it really works on the assessment
Every surveyor knows depreciation reduces a claim. A nil-dep policy does not remove that calculation — it changes what happens to it at the last step. Here is the part-by-part logic, and a worked example showing exactly how the reimbursement appears on the final sheet.
In short
- Depreciation is applied to the value of replaced parts, not to labour — labour is paid in full.
- The rate depends on the material of the part and the age of the vehicle; rubber, plastic and nylon parts carry a fixed higher rate.
- On an ordinary policy the computed depreciation is deducted from the claim.
- On a nil-dep policy the same figure is still computed, then added back / reimbursed — so it must be shown clearly, not simply hidden.
- Nil-dep does not waive the compulsory excess, salvage, or non-admissible items.
What depreciation actually is
A motor own-damage claim indemnifies the insured for loss — it puts them back roughly where they were, not in a better position. When a three-year-old bumper is replaced with a brand-new one, the insured gains a little: an old part is swapped for new. Depreciation is the adjustment for that gain. It is charged on the price of the replaced part, so a part that is repaired rather than replaced carries no part-depreciation at all, and labour is never depreciated.
How the rate is decided
Two things set the depreciation percentage on a part: what the part is made of, and how old the vehicle is.
Material-fixed parts
Rubber, nylon, plastic parts, tyres and tubes, and batteries carry standard fixed rates regardless of a long age table — for example a flat rate on rubber/plastic and a separate rate on tyres and batteries. Glass is typically taken at nil depreciation.
Metal & general parts
Painted sheet-metal and general parts follow an age slab that rises with the vehicle's age — nil in the first few months, then stepping up year by year to a ceiling for older vehicles.
Paint has its own treatment: on a repair, depreciation is applied to the material component of the painting charge, so the paint material is depreciated while the painting labour is not.
Worked example — ordinary policy
Take a simple claim with illustrative figures:
- Front bumper (plastic) — part price ₹ 6,000, depreciation @ 30% = ₹ 1,800
- Bonnet (metal) — part price ₹ 9,000, depreciation @ 10% = ₹ 900
- Labour (replacement + fitting) — ₹ 2,500, no depreciation
- Paint material — ₹ 2,000, depreciation @ 50% on material = ₹ 1,000
Parts + paint material = ₹ 17,000; total depreciation = ₹ 3,700. On an ordinary policy that ₹ 3,700 is deducted. The assessed amount before excess is ₹ 17,000 − ₹ 3,700 + ₹ 2,500 labour = ₹ 15,800, then the compulsory excess and any salvage come off.
The same claim — nil-dep policy
Under a zero-depreciation policy the surveyor still computes that ₹ 3,700 exactly as above — the figure must be visible on the sheet for transparency. The difference is the final move: instead of deducting it, the sheet adds it back as reimbursed.
Ordinary
Parts & paint ₹ 17,000 − depreciation ₹ 3,700 + labour ₹ 2,500 = ₹ 15,800 (before excess & salvage).
Nil-dep
Same ₹ 3,700 computed, then added back as reimbursed → parts allowed at full ₹ 17,000 + labour ₹ 2,500 = ₹ 19,500 (before excess & salvage).
The ₹ 3,700 is the value of the nil-dep add-on to this insured on this claim. That is why a good assessment sheet never simply suppresses depreciation on a nil-dep claim — it shows the computed amount and then an explicit “Add back: depreciation — reimbursed under nil-dep” line, so the insurer, the insured and any auditor can all see the logic.
What nil-dep does NOT remove
This is where disputes arise, so be explicit in the report:
- Compulsory excess / deductible — still applies and is still deducted.
- Salvage — the value of replaced damaged parts (where retained by the insured) is still accounted for.
- Non-admissible items — wear-and-tear parts, pre-existing damage and consumables not related to the accident stay out of the claim.
- Betterment beyond the add-on — nil-dep covers depreciation on parts; it does not turn an inadmissible repair into an admissible one.